SUPERMARKET-GATE: BBC Radio Cambridgeshire interviews expose ‘mavericks’ dilemma that goes to heart of Melton’s planning crisis

23:47 13 October 2012

Conservative councillor for Chatteris Slade Lode Florence Newell

Conservative councillor for Chatteris Slade Lode Florence Newell


HOURS after being sacked from his planning committee, Councillor Florence Newell offered Fenland Council Leader Alan Melton her support but still insisted ‘market forces’ should determine supermarket-gate.

“I will never change my mind and I am still of the opinion both Tesco and Sainsbury should be approved and let market forces determine it,” she told BBC Radio Cambridgeshire.

And despite Cllr Melton insisting and on a different Radio Cambridgeshire programme that allowing two superstores would “decimate” the town, Cllr Newell was unrepentant.

Cllr Melton had attacked those “mavericks out there who would say the free market should decide, build them two, build both of them, and let the market decide.

“I’m sorry, but it’s not as simple as that. There are such issues to be taken into concern such as the viability of town centres, which is very important to the local economy.”

Cllr Newell meanwhile laid the blame at planning officers for their “very misleading” information which, when corrected, meant, in her opinion, Tesco had been given a raw deal.

“I think there were some new councillors (on the planning committee) and they probably didn’t realise advice from planning officers was very misleading,” she told presenter Andie Harper.

When it came back to be ratified, she said, “some members changed their mind.

“Sainsbury’s still have the go ahead; when this further information came forward about roundabout and land, which had been left out, it made some members of planning committee feel we had been very unfair to Tesco.”

But Cllr Melton had earlier told Paul Stainton on his breakfast show that the council was faced with a major problem now both stores had been approved.

“We have two standing supermarket applications approved, whereas our advice from all of our planning consultants is that Whittlesey can only take one store,” he said.

“This would have meant two stores operating in Whittlesey, (which) would decimate the town centre.”

Cllr Melton also explained why he felt the vice chairman of planning, Councillor Martin Curtis, had to go.

“If you want my opinion, and Martin wants my opinion, I believe, and I did tell Martin this, that he has allowed himself to get too emotionally involved with one particular planning application,” said Cllr Melton.

“And the perception out there, he probably doesn’t want to hear this, but this is a fact, the perception out there is Martin has allowed himself to get too close.”

He added: “What I’m saying is I believe in this instance, that the conduct and the way things were run, it wasn’t run correctly.

“And I intend to do something about that. What I want to do is make one thing quite clear. I’m not suggesting in any way whatsoever that those decisions that were made were wrong.

“That’s for the correct committee to decide. What I’m saying is that when those decisions are made, and for whatever reason they should be purely on planning grounds, and planning grounds only, and not on emotional grounds.”


  • re Chris Flattley comments: Chatteris already has 2 supermarkets,and far from being delusional she has accepted that residents of Whittlesey wanted at least the Sainsbury application approved...Tesco have already held their planning permission for a number of years and have done NOTHING.

    Report this comment

    allan best

    Sunday, October 14, 2012

  • re Allan Best. Whittlesey, March & Wisbech all have a co-op. It is not one of the big 4 so can be discounted as such. You can't really count the old Somerfield either.

    Report this comment

    Chris Flattley

    Sunday, October 14, 2012

  • Is this lady for real? Maybe we should build 2 supermarkets in Chatteris and see how she feels about that. I doubt she would be agreeance to market forces determining the outcome. Yet another example of a Cllr in it for themselves. She is delusional if she thinks it would work - especially in towns as small as Whittlesey where it cannot sustain both. It is only sustainable in the bigger towns such as March & Wisbech because of the higher numbers of residents. Simple numbers Cllr!

    Report this comment

    Chris Flattley

    Sunday, October 14, 2012

  • Well you can't expect councillors to understand numbers even simple ones. The thing that strikes me when you meet these people is how unintelligent they are - well most of them. IQ lower than room temperature. No wonder the process goes awry. There should be an intelligence test,

    Report this comment


    Sunday, October 14, 2012

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

More news stories

23 minutes ago
Charity cheque presentation to Facet from Cromwell college students Left: Caitlin Clark, Georgina Dale, Facet manager Jane Clifton and Shannon Buckton. Picture: Steve Williams.

Three Cromwell Community College students banded together to raise more than £165 for a charity which supports people with learning disabilities.

Yesterday, 12:00
Richmond Fellowship Health and Wellbeing Fair at March Town Hall. Isle college students working on nail bar.Picture: Steve Williams.

A national charity devoted to supporting people with mental health problems held a health and well being fair at March.

Yesterday, 09:09
Chairman of govenors Ben Gibbs and principal Catherine Jekinson-Dix have both resigned.

The entire governing body of Ely College was dissolved at a special meeting on Thursday – hours before the principal and two vice principals also announced they were leaving.

Yesterday, 09:00
long serving employee Mick Oakey who retires after 37 years.Mick with his retirement cake.Picture: Steve Williams.

A company stalwart has decided to call it a day after 37 years ... so it was only fitting for him to be thrown a leaving do on Wednesday.

Most read stories

Most commented stories

Digital Edition

Read the Cambs Times e-edition today E-edition