Book Review: The Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes: Sherlock Holmes Vs Dracula

10:41 29 January 2013

Sherlock Holmes vs Dracula

Sherlock Holmes vs Dracula

Archant

By Loren D Estleman, published by Titan Books

HAVING previously encountered the likes of Batman, Tarzan, Jack the Ripper, the Invisible Man and Fu Manchu across various media, it was surely only a matter of time before the Great Detective encountered the King of Vampires.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, Estleman’s novel isn’t the only tale of a confrontation between Sherlock and Vlad, but as well as being the first, it’s also far from a straightforward clash. It has the distinction of being a retelling of Bram Stoker’s original Dracula novel with the interesting addition of Holmes and Watson, whilst maintaining the continuity of the source material.

The arrival of Count Dracula in Victorian England is accompanied by a spate of murders which attract the attention of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s signature creations, who head to Whitby to investigate, where they discover the undead wretch that is Lucy Westenra and are warned off by vampire hunter Abraham Van Helsing.

Estleman deftly inserts his adventure in narrative gaps found in Stoker’s book, with Dracula clashing with Holmes at such times as he wasn’t dealing with the machinations of Van Helsing and his allies.

Purists may frown at the idea of the super-sleuth accepting the existence of vampires, but it’s handled with such aplomb that you soon forget this detail and become immersed in the story.

There’s plenty of action amidst the deductive reasoning, and although the conclusion of the book by necessity does not end in a battle to the death between the protagonists (in order that the Count might die beneath Quincey Morris’ blade at the novel’s climax) it is no less satisfying as a result.

Blending the styles of two different authors can’t be easy, but Estleman perfectly captures Doyle’s characters and prose while also doing justice to Stoker’s own work.

Fast-paced, fun and atmospheric, this is a worthy addition to the legacy of two of literature’s greatest characters.

Alex Mathew

Family and friends have been left shocked and devastated at the death of 19-year-old Alex Matthews.

37 minutes ago
Cambridge Crown Court.

Two drug dealers from March who were arrested after a tip off to police because of the smell of cannabis from the home of one of them been spared jail.

51 minutes ago
Last year, Fenland District Council ran a campaign to highlight the problem of dog fouling by spraying mess left behind by owners. Cllr Peter Murphy is pictured spraying some poop in Wisbech Park.

The possibility of posting dog poop back to owners who fail to remove it from public spaces was discussed at last night’s meeting of Fenland District Council.

Quniton Carroll gives a talk at the March Society meeting.

Fifty people attended The March Society’s talk given by Cambridgeshire Archaeologist Quinton Carroll on ‘Stonea camp, the Iceni and the Romans’.

Most read stories

Most commented stories

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Cambs Times e-edition today E-edition