Auditor says ‘complexity’ of the investigation delays final report of probe into deputy leader’s farms estate tenancy
PUBLISHED: 18:18 17 September 2019 | UPDATED: 18:18 17 September 2019
An inquiry into the awarding of a county council farms tenancy to its deputy leader has proved more complex than was first thought, says a report by a senior auditor.
The findings were widely expected to be considered by this month's audit committee of Cambridgeshire County Council but these have been delayed.
Under investigation is county councillor Roger Hickford whose tenancy of the council owned Manor Farm, Girton, only became widely known sometime after he had moved in. Many councillors only became aware when the commercial and investment committee agreed to finance a £183,000 loan to enable Cllr Hickford to extend the farmhouse.
An inquiry into the affair was widened earlier this year to include the running of the entire 33,000 acre farms estate and its 200 tenancies.
Duncan Wilkinson, head of internal audit, will update the audit committee next week with news of the Manor Farm tenancy investigation and associated work.
"The complexity of the Manor Farm tenancy investigation has proved greater than initially expected," he will report.
"Additionally, as a result of findings made during the review it has been necessary to undertake an additional, separate audit of the county farms service as a whole."
You may also want to watch:
A county council spokeswoman said: "The chief internal auditor has confirmed to the chair of audit and accounts committee that while the audit into both the Manor Farm tenancy and a comprehensive review of the county farms tenancy process is now materially complete, fact checking is still ongoing.
"The fact checking wasn't complete in time for the papers to be submitted to be considered at the September 24 meeting."
The spokeswoman added: "The council has a duty to all parties and stakeholders to properly consider any issue referred for audit
"This process requires confidentiality until these issues have been fully and properly considered, after which the audits will be presented and discussed in public by the audit and accounts committee."
The inquiry was prompted after Lucy Nethsingha, then leader of the Lib Dems on the council, set out seven questions to which she wanted answers.
She also wanted assurances about "the relationship Cllr Hickford had with officers in the county farms department at Shire Hall, and whether these relationships might be expected to influence their ability to make unbiased judgements of any tenancy application made by Cllr Hickford."
Cllr Hickford applied for the tenancy of Manor Farm, Girton, whilst chairman of the former assets committee that had overall responsibility for the council's farms estate.
If you value what this story gives you, please consider supporting the Cambs Times. Click the link in the orange box above for details.