Judge dismisses case against man charged with murder of Wisbech father Terry McSpadden

Terry McSpadden.

Terry McSpadden. - Credit: Archant

A JUDGE has dismissed a case against a man who had been charged with the murder of Wisbech father Terry McSpadden.

Terry McSpadden.

Terry McSpadden. - Credit: Archant

This afternoon, Judge Jacobs threw out the case against Jonathon Porter, 32, of Outwell Road, Elm, citing insufficient evidence.

Father-of-two Mr McSpadden, 24, was last seen in March 2007, visiting a cashpoint on his way home from a pub in Elm. Although he has never been found a murder charge was brought.

This afternoon, Mr Porter was allowed to walk free from Norwich Crown Court by Judge Jacobs.

Det Supt John Brocklebank, Head of the Norfolk and Suffolk Major Investigation Team, said: “This was a difficult investigation which was carried out over several years and involved close working with the Crown Prosecution Service.


You may also want to watch:


“Based on the evidence gathered and advice from counsel, a decision was taken in November 2012 to charge Jonathon Porter with the murder of Terry McSpadden.

“In light of today’s decision, we will now go away and review our investigation in conjunction with the CPS to determine any other opportunities which may now be available.”

Most Read

Frank Ferguson, senior district crown prosecutor, said: “We were satisfied there was sufficient evidence for a realistic prospect of conviction and that the case should go to court.

“Following an application by the defence, which we contested, the judge has ruled that the case should not go ahead. We will be looking at the reasons for this to see if there are any lessons to be learned.”

Det Supt Brocklebank added: “A large number of officers worked on this case as a missing person inquiry, and this continues as a murder inquiry.

“Exactly six years after Terry was reported missing, his family still do not know what happened to him and we will continue our investigation to give them answers and find him.

“Terry was well known in the local community, known as a reliable, hard worker by his employers, and had two young children and strong local ties.”

Anyone with information about Mr McSpadden’s death or the whereabouts of his body, should call the Norfolk and Suffolk Major Investigation Team on 101.

Become a Supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Become a Supporter